It’s that time of year again. October leads the march for the next three months when sweets become one of the central issues for many families. Everywhere you turn there are suckers, cupcakes, frosted cookies and mini chocolate bars. In my local community, Trick or Treat is still happening (with plenty of safety recommendations in place).
A lot of parents are worried about monitoring it and about kids whacked out on sugar and about arguments every morning about how many pieces and when. They’re worried about kids eating so much that they don’t eat dinner or who have pixie stix for breakfast.
On the other hand, kids love Halloween because they love candy. It’s not just the candy itself that they love; they also love the getting of candy. They love the having of candy. And yes, they love the eating of candy. But for a lot of kids, the fun of candy comes with the drag-down of guilt because they know their parents don’t like it. Then the candy starts seeming like a much more complicated prize.
A child listens to their parents lament about the egg nog and the Reeses peanut butter pumpkins, all those holiday pounds they want not to gain. The morning news shows do features on how to stay thin over the dreaded holiday season. Then the child is faced with cookies, the holiday pies, the bowl of M&Ms in autumn colors. They eat it all up, they ea too much because it delicious. They want it and they never see it any other time of year. And then the shame, the disapproval. The adults who shake their heads when they reach for another slice of pumpkin pie or break off another piece of gingerbread house. They listens to their relatives praise someone for turning down the gravy or for having another serving of salad instead of the candied yams. The child comes home with a bag of candy and their parents take it away. Later that night they sneak a piece from the stash their parents hid in the top cupboard, tip-toeing off with the stolen Twix bar, guilt, pleasure and shame mixed with the melting chocolate in their mouth. They spend the time at the holiday celebration trying not to think about the chocolate gelt they’ll go home with, wondering if they can eat it all on the ride home before their parents take it away.
These are the stories I hear from kids but from adult, too, who remember being that kid.
That’s not what we want for our children, right?
Halloween and all the rest of the holidays are a great opportunity for typical kids to learn eating competence. Young kids might need your help so after the candy sorting and counting, let them pick some out to keep for themselves (because remember having is part of the fun) and then put the rest away to distribute at the lunch or dinner table not doled out with worried counting, but put by their plate without comment. If they eat it before the meal, no problem. Give them enough that there’s still room for the other food you serve but don’t fret about the order in which they eat.
(Imagine that — a world where candy is just food! Nothing else! Food you can eat just like any other food, because you like it and your body welcomes it! Food that is not better or worse than broccoli, which leaves you room to notice that sugar is not filling, that sometimes you want something savory. Imagine that!)
Bigger kids can be left to manage their own intake and yes, they will likely make mistakes. They might gorge themselves and get sick and they might show up for dinner too full to eat. Instead of shaming them or taking the candy away, let them figure it out. What have they learned? What will they do different tomorrow? Mistakes are part of growing and really, how bad is the mistake of eating too much Halloween candy? It won’t end up on your permanent record or keep you out of college or get you arrested. It’s just candy.
You will find that when left to their own devices that every kid will handle it differently. Some will count out the days and give themselves a candy allowance. Some will eat it all over a few days and be done with it. Some will forget they have it and you’ll find it next Halloween when you go to unpack the treat bags. How they handle it is morally neutral because there are lots of right ways to handle it. What’s most important is that they learn to listen to their own bellies and they learn to manage their own intake.
If this all sounds too hard or too crazy, please check out Katja Rowell and Ellyn Satter. They both have web sites with a ton of great insight (and lots and lots of research) to help you feel empowered to grow children who can eat competently. You are not alone in this. There is lots of information and lots of help. You really can enjoy the holidays and feeding kids all at the same time!